top of page

BNSF Urges Regulators to Kill Union Pacific Deal as Shippers Cite Fear of Retaliation

6 minutes ago
2 min read

BNSF Railway asked federal regulators on Wednesday to reject Union Pacific Corp.’s proposed takeover of Norfolk Southern Corp., filing a brief backed by more than 130 exhibits on the final day for public comment in the largest rail merger in US history.


The Berkshire Hathaway-owned railroad said the combination would hand one carrier roughly half of all US rail shipments and leave more than 10,000 customer facilities without a competing railroad. “UP will be UP, with more market power,” the brief argued. In a letter to customers, BNSF dismissed Union Pacific’s “Great Connection” branding: “It’s really a Great Concentration.”



BNSF had set out in September the access, pricing and terminal conditions it would seek if the deal were approved. On Wednesday it said those conditions were necessary but not sufficient, and that the Surface Transportation Board should deny the application outright. Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern say the merger would remove 2.1 million truckloads from highways each year and save shippers $3.5 billion annually.


The deadline brought a wave of filings from shippers, senators and state attorneys general, many of them citing Chief Executive Officer Jim Vena’s remarks at a March shippers’ conference in Houston, where he was accused of threatening to raise rates on customers who opposed the deal. “The fear of retaliation for opposing the merger, whether the merger is approved or denied, is real,” the National Grain and Feed Association told the board. The group, whose members operate more than 9,600 facilities, said no conditions could offset the loss of competition.


One trade body declined to take a position at all. The Private Railcar Food and Beverage Association told the board it would not comment “due to the current environment,” according to a filing by its lawyer, former board chairman Daniel Elliott.


The board has said it will not tolerate retaliation against participants. Preliminary views from the Justice and Transportation departments are due Dec. 3.

Comments


bottom of page